picture above: The Pub by the poolside
picture above: The pub
picture above: KLCC view from the pub (before it got blurry...)Discussions about Apartments, Landed Properties, Houses, Homes, Condominiums, Real Estate, Properties, Realty, Terrace Houses, Semi Detached, Bungalows, Detached Houses, Serviced Apartments investments or own stay in Kuala Lumpur, Penang, Malaysia and other exciting places
picture above: The Pub by the poolside
picture above: The pub
picture above: KLCC view from the pub (before it got blurry...)
So, what is the attraction of Desa Kudalari? There are basically 2 main types of layouts here - the large 800+sf low rise 1 bedroom cabana units and a high rise building housing 2 bedroom units. The cabana units have an interesting set-up. They are basically 3 storey walk ups or walk downs with no more than 2 flight of stairs to get to the highest unit because the 2nd floor is actually at the ground level. The 2 bedroom units are approximately 1400sf consisting of 1 master bedroom and 1 smaller bedroom both sharing an adjoining bath. There is a small maid's room next to the kitchen but most owners knock it down to have a larger and brighter kitchen. The living room comes with a small toilet cum powder room.


As mentioned about the maid's room, the 2 bedroom units are architecturally very primitive. The kitchen has no windows and it even has a back door, preumably so that the maid does not share the same entrance as her masters. Unfortunately, the floor plan is such that your main entrance could be facing somebody else's back door. Not quite a feng shui favourite. However, Malaysia does not yet have this en-bloc law. So it may be some time before one can take fruits of this investment. But the value and the quality of the land in Desa Kudalari is certainly worth waiting for.
Launched as Goldhill Gardens more than 3 years back, the project was handed over for vacant possession early this year. It consists of 1 bedroom, 2 bedroom, 3 bedroom and 4 bedroom units ranging from 771sf to almost 3000sf. The 1 bedroom units, all of them facing a courtyard with views of other units are particularly popular. Apparently, all the 40 units of 1 bedroom units are fully tenanted. 



While the 1 bedrooms are apparently doing particularly well with tenancies between RM3500/month to RM4000/month, the bigger units aren't really that popular. The developer emphasized that the occupancy rate is around 40% despite only taken vacant possession a few months ago (that's like almost 10 months ago mind you...). When pressed for who the tenants might be, references to Technip's staffs next door kept popping up. I wonder how many people who work for Technip would live here.
It is not surprising the relatively low occupancy rate considering when one stepped into the condo being greeted by loud pounding noises for the neighbouring construction. It is almost unbearble especially in the courtyard area which faces the construction directly as it acts like a well to collect all the noise. Still, the 2 bedroom units are trying for a RM5500/month rental tag.
picture above: The courtyard facing the construction site
Of all the units, those facing the construction site and Bukit Bintang provides the more sought after views. However, once the high rise office is up, the view will be blocked. In fact, the units facing Bukit Bintang will risk losing the view (...and privacy) when the vacant lot next to it becomes a new construction site. It is currently a car park.
picture above: The parking lot and the bungalow beside is which the 3 bedroom units are facing will soon become a construction site
In my opinion, the lack of proper view is a particular concern as it kind of takes the shine off high-rise living in this KLCC area. Indeed, Bintang Goldhill is located within the fringe of the 1km radius of KLCC. Well,... almost 1.2km really.... But no units will eventually have any view of KLCC because they will soon be blocked. Other units are literally facing the wall of Wisma Technip or the busy and noisy, not to mention polluted Jalan Tun Razak or they could be facing the courtyard with other neighbours spying directly into your window. Perhaps the better views are the larger units facing the swimming pool but they are sold out.
To make up for the negative parts, Goldhill spared no dime to make this a truly classy place. One is greeted by an Italian marble and granite foyer upon entry.
The facilities are alos top notch with a well equipped gym, steam sauna, swimming pool etc etc...





However, there are still a few units of Type 8 which has a similar concept (i.e. a larger 3 bedroom 3 bathroom unit with an adjoining studio which has a separate entrance). I reckon Type 8 is not as popular as it is a corner unit which has a wall facing the hotel and the rest is overlooking ... Cheras...
The showroom at the site models the Type 8 which in my opinion is a disappointment. The kitchen is really too small and dim with a connecting maid's room. The bathroom connected to the maid's room is really just a toilet and a sink. The maid will have to share your bathroom as I cannot see any possibility of installing a shower within the tiny space...

Picture above: The larger Type 8 unit's kitchen is really too small and dim

Picture above: Type 8's 3rd bedroom

Final verdict on this?
Well, the smaller studios are probably a better buy considering the benchmark that Times Square has set at RM2500/month rental. The low density of studios compared to Casa Mutiara and Times Square would mean little internal competition and faster movement. Type 7 although sold out would be a value buy if it comes out into the sub-sale market especially if it is a firesale in the rougher economic doldrum next year when Taragon Puteri is expected to be completed end of 2009 (bad timing).
The location is not exactly great, especially when one needs to negotiate crime and vice infested backlanes of Imbi to get to Times Square and the monorail station. Hopefully, the prestige of an international-grade hotel will change the neighbourhood for the better. Getting to Bukit Bintang by car is also not straight-forward due to the one-way road scheme.
The building you see above is actually a 3 in 1. At the front is Menara Chan, an office. In the middle and the main lobby houses Seri Maya hotel, a 4 star hotel. And at the back is Plaza 138, another office block with individual owners and strata title. Location is directly opposite BSN tower and in between the KLCC and Dang Wangi LRT station. It is also about 400m from the Bukit Nanas monorail station. I would consider this a prestigious address... not sure about those familiar with the commercial market. Please advice.The unit in question is in Plaza 138. Despite the excellent location, one of my quarrels with it is, Plaza 138's entrance is actually at the middle of the building which, if you don't know you might not be able to find it. However, it is directly opposite the entrance of Seri Maya hotel's lobby.

picture above: Top view of the main entrance
Plaza 138 is basically quadrangle. There is a center courtyard which is actually the swimming pool of Seri Maya hotel. You can barely see it when you look down because it is covered with a bamboo roof. It is served by 2 very slow lifts but they seem well maintained and looks very classy with a lot of marble and stainless steel.

picture above: Top view of Swimming pool
What attracted me to Plaza 138 is that every office includes a small pantry, a shower and a toilet within the unit. So, this means it can be turned into a SOHO unit if the tenant wants to live in it. It can be renovated in such a way that it's partially residential and partially office. Just needs imagination.

The main issue of course is the Muslim graveyard behind the building. Unfortunately, every unit has a nice view of the grave yard. I would imagine that this would affect the feng shui of businesses as well as the ability to find a tenant who would like to live or work so close to the graveyard.
From my understanding, the rental fetches about RM4.50psf/month but it does not come with car park. You have to rent the car park separately from the building management at RM160/month per plot on availability basis. During my visit, the offices are about 80% occupied. I would say, the rental and the price is reasonable for the location but the graveyard is really a big issue. For me, one who works late every night, I would have a problem and would have an even bigger problem convincing my staffs to stay late and finish their work.


picture above: Type G at Block B is a corner unit, with a rounded window in the Master Bedroom
Picture above: Type G in Block B has a 2nd bedroom which is quite big in size and has it's own attached bathroom
Picture above: The living room and kitchen is rather narrow. This bar will need to be demolished.
There is no doubt that the rental demand is very strong for lower cost city center condominiums. By lower cost, I mean:
And by city center, I don't mean Sri Hartamas, Bangsar or Mont Kiara....
I am not too surprised that the available units for sale now are asking 30% higher than last year's price. For example, a 2 bedroom unit was auctioned from RM240k last year and finally sold at RM280k. This year, the minimum asking price for a 2 bedroom unit is RM340k. However, this makes it harder to justify because rent has not increased a great deal. take a 1 bedroom unit for example, the rental 2 years ago is in the range RM1200 to RM1500. This year, I have seen units rented out for RM1800. Perhaps the owners have done some renovations and bought new furnishings.
Also due to it's location, Mutiara Villa has in the past few years been dogged by security issues. It is so easy for people to just walk in and there are all sorts of people in this part of Bukit Bintang. Many residents tell me that the crime are mostly committed from within. This is quite possible. An agent who started operating in this building has been making quick rentals by renting to immigrant workers. As many owners live outstation or overseas entrusts their keys to this agent, they are not aware about what's going on except for receiving rental money monthly in their bank account. Some of these units have 10 and even 15 occupants! They made their presence felt by gathering in the lobby and swimming pool deck, sometimes creating a nuisance.
Why then am I still interested in Mutiara Villa?
Well, first of all, it's location, location and ... location. Secondly, there is a ray of hope now that a new management company has taken over. Security gantries and a key card system is being introduced. I understand that owners will soon be forced to register their tenants and only a limited number of keycards will be issued for each units to prevent them from being turned into dormitories. If serious action is taken, I am confident that Mutiara Villa can return to its former glory.